Functional and Nonfunctional Requirements: Specification and Types
Clearly defined requirements are essential signs on the road that leads to a successful project. They establish a formal agreement between a client and a provider that they are both working to reach the same goal. High-quality, detailed requirements also help mitigate financial risks and keep the project on a schedule. According to the Business Analysis Body of Knowledge (BABOK) definition, requirements are a usable representation of a need.
Creating requirements is a complex task as it includes a set of processes such as elicitation, analysis, specification, validation, and management. In this article, we’ll discuss the main types of requirements for software products and provide a number of recommendations for their use.
Types of requirements
BABOK, which is a recognized set of business analysis industry standards, offers the following classification of requirements.
These include high-level statements of goals, objectives, and needs. Business requirements do not include any details or specific features. They just state the problem and the business objective to be achieved such as
- increased revenue/throughput/customer reach,
- reduced expenses/errors,
- improved customer service, etc.
User (stakeholder) requirements
The needs of discrete stakeholder groups (top-level managers, nonmanagement staff, customers, etc.) are specified to define what they expect from a particular solution. This group serves as a bridge between the generalized business requirements and specific solution requirements. They are outlined in a User Requirements Specification and can include, for example, ability to create various reports, view order history and status, manage customer databases, etc.
Solution requirements describe specific characteristics that a product must have to meet the needs of the stakeholders and the business itself. They fall into two large groups.
- Functional requirements define what a product must do, what its features and functions are.
- Nonfunctional requirements describe the general properties of a system. They are also known as quality attributes.
An additional group of requirements defines what is needed from an organization to successfully move from its current state to its desired state with the new product. They are only necessary for the short period of time while the transition takes place. Examples can be “users must be trained to operate the system” or “previous data must be migrated to the cloud storage.”
This article is focused on functional and nonfunctional types of requirements. Before diving into the detailed description, let’s compare them side by side.
Functional vs nonfunctional requirements
Functional requirements are product features or functions that developers must implement to enable users to accomplish their tasks. So, it’s important to make them clear both for the development team and the stakeholders. Generally, functional requirements describe system behavior under specific conditions. For example:
The system sends an approval request after the user enters personal information.
A search feature allows a user to hunt among various invoices if they want to credit an issued invoice.
The system sends a confirmation email when a new user account is created.
Nonfunctional requirements, not related to the system functionality, rather define how the system should perform. Some examples are:
The website pages should load in 3 seconds with the total number of simultaneous users <5 thousand.
The system should be able to handle 20 million users without performance deterioration.
Here’s a brief comparison and then we’ll proceed to a more in-depth explanation of each group.
Functional vs nonfunctional requirements
Types of functional requirements and their specifications
Functional requirements can be classified according to different criteria. For example, we can group them on the basis of the functions a given feature must perform in the end product. Of course, they would differ depending on the product being developed, but for the sake of an example, the types of functional requirements might be
- Authorization levels
- Compliance to laws or regulations
- External interfaces
- Transactions processing
- Business rules, etc.
Requirements are usually written in text, especially for Agile-driven projects. However, they may also be visuals. Here are the most common formats and documents:
- Software requirements specification document
- Use cases
- User stories
- Work Breakdown Structure (WBS), or functional decomposition
- Models and diagrams
Let’s see what each of them is about.
Software requirements specification document
Both functional and nonfunctional requirements can be formalized in the software requirements specification (SRS) document. To learn more about software documentation in general, read our article on that topic. The SRS contains descriptions of functions and capabilities that the product must provide. The document also defines constraints and assumptions. The SRS can be a single document communicating functional requirements or it may accompany other software documentation like user stories and use cases.
We don’t recommend composing SRS for the entire solution before the development kick-off, but you should document the requirements for every single feature before actually building it. Once you receive the initial user feedback, you can update the document.
SRS must include the following sections:
Purpose. Definitions, system overview, and background.
Overall description. Assumptions, constraints, business rules, and product vision.
Specific requirements. System attributes, functional requirements, and database requirements.
It’s essential to make the SRS readable for all stakeholders. You also should use templates with visual emphasis to structure the information and aid in understanding it. If you have requirements stored in some other document formats, provide a link to them so that readers can find the needed information.
Example: If you’d like to see an actual document, download this SRS example created at Michigan State University, which includes all points mentioned above in addition to presenting use cases to illustrate parts of the product. Below is a concise list of SRS contents.
A template for a software requirements specification, source: Software Requirements by Karl Wiegers Joy Beatty
Use cases describe the interaction between the system and external users that leads to achieving particular goals.
Each use case includes three main elements:
Actors. These are the external users that interact with the system.
System. The system is described by functional requirements that define an intended behavior of the product.
Goals. The purposes of the interaction between the users and the system are outlined as goals.
There are two formats to represent use cases:
- Use case specification structured in textual format
- Use case diagram
A use case specification represents the sequence of events along with other information that relates to this use case. A typical use case specification template includes the following information:
- Pre- and Post- interaction condition
- Basic interaction path
- Alternative path
- Exception path
Use case specification template
A use case diagram doesn’t contain a lot of details. It shows a high-level overview of the relationships between actors, different use cases, and the system.
The use case diagram includes the following main elements:
- Use cases. Usually drawn with ovals, use cases represent different interaction scenarios that actors might have with the system (log in, make a purchase, view items, etc.).
- System boundaries. Boundaries are outlined by the box that groups various use cases in a system.
- Actors. These are the figures that depict external users (people or systems) that interact with the system.
- Associations. Associations are drawn with lines showing different types of relationships between actors and use cases.
Use case diagram example
A user story is a documented description of a software feature seen from the end-user perspective. The user story describes what exactly the user wants the system to do. In Agile projects, user stories are organized in a backlog, which is an ordered list of product functions. Currently, user stories are considered to be the best format for backlog items.
A typical user story is written like this:
As a <type of user>, I want <some goal> so that <some reason>.
As an admin, I want to add descriptions to products so that users can later view these descriptions and compare the products.
User stories must be accompanied by acceptance criteria. These are the conditions that the product must satisfy to be accepted by a user, stakeholders, or a product owner. Each user story must have at least one acceptance criterion. Effective acceptance criteria must be testable, concise, and completely understood by all team members and stakeholders. They can be written as checklists, plain text, or by using Given/When/Then format.
Here’s an example of the acceptance criteria checklist for a user story describing a search feature:
- A search field is available on the top-bar.
- A search is started when the user clicks Submit.
- The default placeholder is a grey text Type the name.
- The placeholder disappears when the user starts typing.
- The search language is English.
- The user can type no more than 200 symbols.
- It doesn’t support special symbols. If the user has typed a special symbol in the search input, it displays the warning message: Search input cannot contain special symbols.
Finally, all user stories must fit the INVEST quality model:
- I – Independent
- N – Negotiable
- V – Valuable
- E – Estimable
- S – Small
- T – Testable
Independent. This means that you can schedule and implement each user story separately. This is very helpful if you implement continuous integration processes.
Negotiable. This means that all parties agree to prioritize negotiations over specification. This also means that details will be created constantly during development.
Valuable. A story must be valuable to the customer. You should ask yourself from the customer’s perspective “why” you need to implement a given feature.
Estimable. A quality user story can be estimated. This will help a team schedule and prioritize the implementation. The bigger the story is, the harder it is to estimate it.
Small. Good user stories tend to be small enough to plan for short production releases. Small stories allow for more specific estimates.
Testable. If a story can be tested, it’s clear enough and good enough. Tested stories mean that requirements are done and ready for use.
Functional decomposition or Work Breakdown Structures (WBS)
A functional decomposition or WBS is a visual document that illustrates how complex processes break down into their simpler components. WBS is an effective approach to allow for an independent analysis of each part. WBS also helps capture the full picture of the project.
We suggest the following logic of functional decomposition:
- Find the most general function.
- Find the closest sub function.
- Find the next level of sub function.
- Check your diagram.
Or the decomposition process may look like this:
High Level Function ->Sub-function -> Process -> Activity
The features should be decomposed to the point at which the lowest level parts can’t be broken down any further.
An example of a functional decomposition
Software prototype is an umbrella term for different forms of early stage deliverables that are built to showcase how requirements must be implemented. Prototypes help bridge the vision gaps and let stakeholders and teams clarify complicated areas of products in development. Traditionally, prototypes represent how the solution will work and give examples of how users will interact with it to accomplish their tasks.
Prototypes can be cheap and fast visual representations of requirements (throwaway prototypes) or more complex ones (evolutionary prototypes). The latter can even become the early versions of the product that already have some pieces of the final code. Effectively, evolutionary prototypes may even turn into minimum viable products or MVPs that we’ve described in a separate article.
Design documents and prototypes
Design requirements are usually collected and documented using three main formats that morph into one another:
Wireframes. Wireframes are low-fidelity graphic structures of a website or an app. They help map different product pages with sections and interactive elements.
Mockups. Once wireframes are ready, they are turned into mockups, visual designs that convey the look and feel of the final product. Eventually, mockups can become the final design of the product.
Design prototypes. These documents contain visuals and allow for some interface interactions, like scrolling, clicking on links, or filling in forms. Design prototypes can be built from scratch using HTML and CSS, but most UX teams use prototyping services like InVision.
To learn more about how UX design processes are handled, check our case study about building a travel management solution for Cornerstone, a corporate SaaS provider, in which we used all three types of design requirements.
Flight Status interface design of the 4site platform
Nonfunctional requirements examples
As we already mentioned, nonfunctional requirements describe how a system must behave and establish constraints of its functionality. This type of requirements is also known as the system’s quality attributes. If you want detailed information about types of nonfunctional requirements and how to approach and document them, check our dedicated article.
Here, we’ll just briefly describe the most typical nonfunctional requirements.
Usability defines how difficult it will be for a user to learn and operate the system. Usability can be assessed from different points of view:
Efficiency of use: the average time it takes to accomplish a user’s goals, how many tasks a user can complete without any help, the number of transactions completed without errors, etc.
Intuitiveness: how simple it is to understand the interface, buttons, headings, etc.
Low perceived workload: how many attempts users need to accomplish a particular task.
Example: Usability requirements can consider language barriers and localization tasks: People with no understanding of French must be able to use the product. Or you may set accessibility requirements: Keyboard users who navigate a website using <tab>, must be able to reach the “Add to cart” button from a product page within 15 <tab> clicks.
Security requirements ensure that the software is protected from unauthorized access to the system and its stored data. It considers different levels of authorization and authentication across different users roles. For instance, data privacy is a security characteristic that describes who can create, see, copy, change, or delete information. Security also includes protection against viruses and malware attacks.
Example: Access permissions for the particular system information may only be changed by the system’s data administrator.
Reliability defines how likely it is for the software to work without failure for a given period of time. Reliability decreases because of bugs in the code, hardware failures, or problems with other system components. To measure software reliability, you can count the percentage of operations that are completed correctly or track the average period of time the system runs before failing.
Example: The database update process must roll back all related updates when any update fails.
Performance is a quality attribute that describes the responsiveness of the system to various user interactions with it. Poor performance leads to negative user experience. It also jeopardizes system safety when it’s overloaded.
Example: The front-page load time must be no more than 2 seconds for users that access the website using an LTE mobile connection.
Availability is gauged by the period of time that the system’s functionality and services are available for use with all operations. So, scheduled maintenance periods directly influence this parameter. And it’s important to define how the impact of maintenance can be minimized. When writing the availability requirements, the team has to define the most critical components of the system that must be available at all times. You should also prepare user notifications in case the system or one of its parts becomes unavailable.
Example: New module deployment mustn’t impact front page, product pages, and check out pages availability and mustn’t take longer than one hour. The rest of the pages that may experience problems must display a notification with a timer showing when the system is going to be up again.
Scalability requirements describe how the system must grow without negative influence on its performance. This means serving more users, processing more data, and doing more transactions. Scalability has both hardware and software implications. For instance, you can increase scalability by adding memory, servers, or disk space. On the other hand, you can compress data, use optimizing algorithms, etc.
Example: The website attendance limit must be scalable enough to support 200,000 users at a time.
Best practices for documenting requirements
Creating documentation is an integral part of any software development project. Well-documented requirements ensure that stakeholders and developers are on the same page and also help define project scope and budget. Here are a few useful tips on how to make great documentation.
Requirements have to be clear and understandable. Make sure your requirements are stated in a concise manner that doesn’t contain ambiguity or allow different interpretations. Also, try to avoid technological jargon. Remember that each audience is different and stakeholders might not be familiar with specialized tech terminology. Instead, enrich your documents with visuals, diagrams, and graphs to support the information and make it easier to perceive. Adding glossaries and cross-links is also helpful.
Requirements have to be specific, accurate, and complete. When writing your documentation, be consistent with the language and make sure that your requirements are accurate. They should cover every scenario, but never contradict each other. Avoid vagueness and weak phrases such as “system has to be fast” or “when something happens.” Be specific and quantify the terms so that all the readers can understand them in the same way.
Requirements have to be testable. Write requirements in such a way that after the product is created, testing can show whether they are delivered successfully.
Requirements have to be feasible and sensible. Focus on the functionality and quality attributes that users actually need. Remember that requirements have to reflect higher-level business objectives.